THE |
|
a cache of usenet and other text files pertaining
to occult, mystical, and spiritual subjects. |
To: alt.pagan,alt.satanism,alt.religion.all-worlds,alt.magick.tyagi,alt.magick From: tyagi@houseofkaos.abyss.com (nocTifer) Subject: Definitions of Satanists/Neopagans (was Re: Satanist/NeoPagan War) Date: 2 Jul 1996 03:35:28 -0700 kaliyuga 49960701 AA1 Thomas Hrouda: |>...What specifically about Satanism makes you think its not pagan? |> Is it (for the sake of argument) that you don't believe the Satanists |> worship the "OLD GODS"? I'll answer this too. :> the question is ill-asked, as others have already pointed out. without including a ready-made definition for these things we are left with overmuch ambiguity. even so it is worth it to me to speak to it. Satanism isn't "pagan" inasmuch as it doesn't truly participate in preChristian religion. then again, neither does Neopaganism as I see it. ;> in this sense Neopagans aren't "pagan" either. Satanism isn't Neopagan in the sense that it includes elements which extend beyond the circle which the term 'Neopagan' typically enscribes. those elements are being pointed out adequately by Werner and others. Satanism isn't Neopagan in that it doesn't always attempt to recreate previous religious systems, a 'return to the old ways', and yes, many Satanists don't even attempt to lend an appearance of worshipping old gods. these appear to be the elements of Satanism excluded from the Neopagan descriptive as I've come to know it (be sure you understand that I do think there is at least an intersection and that I may well dwell within it, however). Werner Arend: |...Aquino's statement mentioning the "unconscious forces of nature" and |the disconnectedness of human individual consciousness from these would |disqualify him and those who follow his belief from being perceived as |Neo-Pagan by most Neo-Pagans, without further explanation. I'm unsure. there are at least a few Neopagans who think of the gods as 'archetypes', and I don't know why these wouldn't qualify for the type of rhetoric Aquino is using or that which CoSatanists occasionally bring up about 'using the gods during rite'. my own feelings are much more devotional than many Satanists apparently feel. |...see the quotation from [JJ]Assad.... I'll take his "definition", |and then tell you which of his "commonly held beliefs" are most |important to me personally, and why I think that some Satanists |don't qualify. my response to his text also follows. JJAssad: |>...commonalties [for Neopagan].... are: |>The practice of non Judeo-Christian or Muslim monotheistic religions by |>the individual or group in question. often 'The Goddess'. yes, and not favored by many Satanists from what I can tell. |>A commonly held belief of immanent divinity. very often true it seems to me, yes, and I'd say that the idea of 'divinity' here may exclude many Satanists but include others such as myself and perhaps Diane Vera. |>A commonly practiced rejection of the concept of transcendent divinity. my experience isn't similar here. I've known many who enjoyed the concept and even the mystical engagement of the transcendant, and this does also appear true for some Satanists (Setians?). |>A polytheistic predilection towards the divinity forms that antedate |>Judeo-Christianity. or at least which they believe do so, yes, and I think this is also true for some Satanists. |>A fierce disavowal of "herd mentality" with the insistence on |>individuality and freedom of choices. true and almost identical among many, many Satanists, at least within their stated ideologies. |>The open celebration of sensuality and sex. eroticism, hedonism, yes, and very common among Satanists, both practically and within Satanist literature. |>A commonly held concept of the "Sacred Round" or the Wheel of the Year |>which guides the seasonal celebrations and festivals. again yes, and this is favored by a great many Satanists as well. |>A commonly held reverence for Nature, her creatures and her very |>breast(the land we walk upon). I agree, and this is sometimes true of Satanists such as myself, some elements of orgSatanists. |>A sincere disavowal of Judeo-Christianity*(NOT universally held)." this appears to be very common amongst many Neopagans and Satanists, and I think it likely that it is due to reactionary forces. Werner Arend : |The first concept I suspect most Satanists of rejecting is "immanent |divinity". It seems that quite a few Satanists reject the concept of |divinity at all, or recognize divinity *only* in the Ego, instead of the |Self *and* the rest of the universe. Aquino certainly qualifies here. sure, but Aquino and Co. are not the most numerous of the Satanic batch. I'd actually agree here and suggest that many Satanists are actually atheist materialists who utilize their gods in rite for (wonderfully!) selfish purposes, suspending disbelief in the interim. for this reason I'd suggest that nonJCI monotheism would also likely be unpopular among Satanists as it includes 'theism'. |...I suspect many Satanists of being fundamentalists in disguise, |who do not respect others' individuality and freedom of choices.... |...statements [such as] "Respect to those who deserve it." and |"Respect has to be earned." I think 'fundamentalism' may be found in any religion or cult. my own sense is that a great many Satanists actually feel as you do, rejecting this type of aggressive elitism, but I can't be sure. |...who deserves respect is defined by these Satanists. I think this is true within most communities, it is just not acknowledged. |This creates a hierarchy of values, and a society in which the |powerful do not have to respect the individuals less powerful than |themselves. it is this element of some people's Satanism which concerns me most, I must admit (the fascist and neonazi elements especially -- not because Hitler and a study of him and his ways is alien to me or even unattractive to me, but that I don't always know what they mean by it and how they wish it to manifest in their lives). |eliminates individual freedom for everyone but the boss of it all. if there is a boss, yes. |The statement that "respect has to be earned" opens wide the door to fascism. this seems rather ambiguous to me as 'respect' is not precisely defined and what we do to or with those whom we do not respect is also not really spelled out. in many Satanic documents the weak and/or disrespected are merely left to fend for themselves. why this of necessity leads to anything like fascism is beyond me. |And that is what I will always answer with a "No!" put as strongly as |possible! I understand that your American constitution bases on the |belief that if there is to be freedom, it has to be freedom (and thus |a minimum of respect!) for everyone. This I subscribe to. I don't think that respect is required by that political document. I gathered that it mostly protects the individual from the tyranny of the governmental institution itself, rather than requiring any particular demonstrations of 'respect' among citizens. I do agree that there are laws which protect us from violation by others, but this would seem to be quite beyond any sort of 'respect' as people normally understand the term. |There are those "anarchist" Satanists who I would accept. [nocTifer] |is a good example. I don't know if he qualifies as a Satanist - I |don't remember him using that label with regard to himself - I am a Satanist by my standards. ;> that is as much as anyone can say unless they mean to imply something regarding membership in some organization. |but he has an affinity to dark gods true. |and probably has no qualms whatsoever about "Black magic". actually I do not personally involve myself with coercive magick in the slightest, being even resistant to retributive workings other than a communication of my pain (as in my curse using the Names of Allah). if you mean to imply here the typical significances of 'Black Magic' used by orgSatanists (CoS/ToS), then I don't really enjoy what is called 'Lesser Black Magic' as it involves manipulation and petty persuasions, though I do think that my expressions are at times intended to achieve this effect (not coercively, persuasively). regarding 'Greater Black Magic' I spend the bulk of my time with it, though not *because* I learned about it from these orgs or truly knew what it was or studied ceremony extensively. LaVey describes this as "the integration of apparent opposites" and he claims that this is the "essence of Satanism and Satanic practices", which I find very intriguing and reflective of my own interests/doings. |...while he strongly rejects any "infringement on his territory", |he respects others' too. I would welcome him as a fellow seeker |in the universe of human consciousness, however different he may |be elsewhere and however different the details of his belief may |be from mine. that is very often true, yes, as can be attested to by the various religious with whom I have lived (atheists, agnostics, secular Jews, Discordians, Wiccans, general Neopagans, Shamanics, etc.). very keen of you to welcome me too. ;> |All those other people, those crying "I'm one of you" and insulting |Neo-Paganism in the same sentence.... who feel that they need not |respect me just because I don't share their opinion, I can perfectly |well do without, and, yes, I *will* attempt to exclude them from |Neo-Paganism because I do not feel that they respect my |individuality, regardless of their being Christians, Satanists |or even other Neo-pagans. well, attempting to 'exclude people from Neopaganism' seems rather a useless endeavor to me. I see it is as likely as those who wish to 'exclude people from Christianity' for similar reasons. there isn't really some Board of Authorization to which one may appeal, though I can see it on a personal basis (through restriction of your personal associations, etc.). nocTifer tyagi@houseofkaos.abyss.com
The Arcane Archive is copyright by the authors cited.
Send comments to the Arcane Archivist: tyaginator@arcane-archive.org. |
Did you like what you read here? Find it useful?
Then please click on the Paypal Secure Server logo and make a small donation to the site maintainer for the creation and upkeep of this site. |
The ARCANE ARCHIVE is a large domain,
organized into a number of sub-directories, each dealing with a different branch of religion, mysticism, occultism, or esoteric knowledge. Here are the major ARCANE ARCHIVE directories you can visit: |
|
interdisciplinary:
geometry, natural proportion, ratio, archaeoastronomy
mysticism: enlightenment, self-realization, trance, meditation, consciousness occultism: divination, hermeticism, amulets, sigils, magick, witchcraft, spells religion: buddhism, christianity, hinduism, islam, judaism, taoism, wicca, voodoo societies and fraternal orders: freemasonry, golden dawn, rosicrucians, etc. |
SEARCH THE ARCANE ARCHIVE
There are thousands of web pages at the ARCANE ARCHIVE. You can use ATOMZ.COM
to search for a single word (like witchcraft, hoodoo, pagan, or magic) or an
exact phrase (like Kwan Yin, golden ratio, or book of shadows):
OTHER ESOTERIC AND OCCULT SITES OF INTEREST
Southern
Spirits: 19th and 20th century accounts of hoodoo,
including slave narratives & interviews
|